Caribbean Cruises Disney Family Travel Guides s-travel Travel Tips

Cruise Line Showdown: Evaluating Carnival, Disney and Royal Caribbean for Households

Last chance reminder! Until Apr. 24, the Marriot Bonvoy Brilliant™ American Express Card and the Marriott Bonvoy Business™ American Express® Card are offering 100,000-point welcome bonuses. The bonuses have identical terms: Spend $5,000 in the first three months to earn 100,000 Marriott points. Terms Apply. When I first started cruising more than 25 years ago, …

Closing probability reminder! Till Apr. 24, the Marriot Bonvoy Sensible™ American Specific Card and the Marriott Bonvoy Industry™ American Specific® Card are providing 100,000-point welcome bonuses. The bonuses have equivalent phrases: Spend $5,000 within the first 3 months to earn 100,000 Marriott issues. Phrases Observe.

Once I first began cruising greater than 25 years in the past, the everyday send used to be heavy with honeymooners and retirees — the “newlywed and just about lifeless,” because the outdated funny story is going. Probably the most thrilling factor for households at the peak deck of many vessels, rather then a pool, used to be a shuffleboard court docket. The road possibly maximum related to relations cruising, Disney Cruise Line, didn’t even exist but. Issues positive have modified.

Harmony of the Seas
Most sensible deck enjoyable on Solidarity of the Seas. (Picture courtesy of Royal Caribbean world)

A number of the traces that dominate the business, the sport more and more is all about households. The sector’s two largest cruise operators — Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean — now draw loads of 1000’s of households a 12 months and, in conjunction with smaller gamers Norwegian Cruise Line and MSC Cruises, are more and more packing their ships with each and every kind of family-friendly enchantment conceivable, from huge waterslides and deck-top “sky rides” to go-kart tracks, bumper-car pavilions and laser-tag classes. Carnival is even making plans a curler coaster for its subsequent vessel.

Briefly, ships are turning into floating variations of probably the most over-the-top relations hotels on land and there’s by no means been a extra thrilling time to check out relations cruising. This is, if you’ll be able to determine the precise send and cruise line for you.

For a first-timer, reserving a relations cruise may also be greater than a little bit overwhelming. Each and every of the aforementioned traces has a special vibe and no two ships — even vessels from the similar collection — are precisely alike.

What’s extra, pricing for relations cruises is in every single place the map. A crusing with Disney can price two or thrice as a lot consistent with day as a crusing with Carnival, Norwegian or MSC.

Within the segments underneath, we provide concerns and pricing comparisons for 3 of the most important gamers within the relations cruise marketplace: Disney, Royal Caribbean and Carnival.

In This Publish

An Assessment of the Traces

You may think Disney is the Hercules of relations cruising — the omnipotent competitor with out a rival. However within the cruise global Disney remains to be reasonably of a distinct segment participant. With simply 4 ships in comparison to the 52 operated via relations cruise giants Carnival and Royal Caribbean, Disney is just like the cruising similar of Olaf from “Frozen” — a little bit secondary to the plot, if nonetheless a lot cherished. On the subject of passenger capability, Disney is just a 10th the dimensions of Royal Caribbean on my own, and it doesn’t be offering just about as various an array of house ports and itineraries.

What Disney does be offering is Disney. From Disney tunes piped into cabin hallways and Disney-shaped meals pieces on menus to Disney-themed night time displays and the promise of assembly your favourite Disney princess, Disney ships are mouse bait for the diehard Mickey lover. If Disney is your factor, not anything in cruising moderately compares. Simply be ready to pay up large time for the privilege of cruising with Captain Mickey or Minnie (extra on that during a second).

Disney Cruise Line mickey beach
Meet your favourite characters aboard a Disney Cruise Line voyage. (Picture courtesy of Disney Cruise Line)

Carnival lengthy has claimed to be the most important cruise line for households, with greater than 800,000 youngsters a 12 months touring on its 26 ships (out of five.2 million general passengers). Recognized for its affordability in addition to its energetic, unpretentious, fun-focused vibe, that is probably the most price range choice of the 3 traces we’re evaluating. You’re more likely to pay significantly much less to sail with Carnival than Royal Caribbean or Disney.

For households yearning the mega-resort revel in, there’s not anything moderately like a Royal Caribbean vessel. The most important of the road’s 26 ships are greater than 70% larger than the most important Disney and Carnival ships afloat and have much more “stuff” that can get your children’ hearts racing — the entirety from rock-climbing partitions and browsing swimming pools to skydiving simulators and ice-skating rinks. Royal Caribbean additionally will provide you with much more alternatives in terms of itineraries. The road can have 8 ships in Europe this summer season, as an example, in comparison to one for Disney and none for Carnival. (Carnival, it will have to be famous, is a line that essentially specializes in cruises out of US ports which might be simple for its budget-conscious consumers to achieve via vehicle or with a brief, affordable flight.)

Evaluating Costs: A Explicit Instance

Typically, on very equivalent itineraries, you’lapay a top class — from time to time an enormous top class — to take your teenagers and children on a Disney send as a substitute of a Royal Caribbean send, and either one of the ones traces will price you greater than Automobile nival. Simply how a lot more? We priced equivalent summer season sailings to the Caribbean at the 3 traces and located a hypothetical relations of 4 would pay about 71% extra to get aboard a Royal Caribbean send than a Carnival send and 163% extra to sail with Disney.

Carnival Breeze Seaside Theatre, a lido deck poolside 270-square-foot LED screen offering nightly “Dive In Movies,” along with concerts, sporting events and other programming throughout the day. (Photo by Andy Newman / Carnival Cruise Line)
Carnival Breeze Seashore Theatre, a lido deck poolside 270-square-foot LED display screen providing nightly “Dive In Films,” in conjunction with concert events, carrying occasions and extra during the day. (Picture via Andy Newman / Carnival Cruise Line)

For the comparability, we checked out explicit seven-night Japanese Caribbean sailings introduced via every line out of Port Canaveral, Florida, for the week of Aug. 10. We selected this routing as it allowed for probably the most apples-to-apples matchups you’ll be able to make between the manufacturers. All 3 of the firms have located one among their latest, snazziest vessels in Port Canaveral for seven-night Caribbean sailings.

In Carnival’s case, it’s Carnival Breeze, which debuted in 2012 and is among the line’s more moderen Vista-class vessels. For Royal Caribbean, it’s Solidarity of the Seas, which started crusing in 2016 and is a part of the road’s in style Oasis category. Disney’s contender out there is Disney Myth, the road’s latest send. It debuted in 2012, simply two months earlier than Carnival Breeze.

When pricing, we assumed we had been reserving a relations with two adults and two youngsters ages Eight and 12 who would percentage a unmarried cabin. We discovered:

  • The least pricey cabin to be had for Carnival Breeze on the time of our pricing would have set our relations again $3,049.88 (a median fare of $632 consistent with consumer, plus $130.97 consistent with consumer in taxes and charges). For that, our relations would have got an Inner with Image Window (Walkway View) cabin measuring 185 sq. ft. Such rooms have two dual beds that convert right into a king mattress, plus a pull-down bunk for one and a settee that converts right into a mattress for one.
  • The least pricey cabin on Royal Caribbean’s Solidarity of the Seas prices $5,221.82 (a median fare of $1,204.26 consistent with consumer, plus $101.20 in taxes and charges). Particularly, that upper value would have got our relations a cabin measuring simply 149 sq. ft — just about 20% smaller than the cabin on Carnival Breeze. As with Carnival, it used to be an inside cabin — on this case with two dual beds that convert right into a king mattress and a double settee mattress.
  • The least pricey cabin on Disney Myth prices a slightly sky-high $8,011.92 (a median fare of $1,907.64 consistent with consumer, plus $95.37 in taxes and charges). For that, our relations would have got a Same old Within Stateroom that measures 169 sq. ft — a little bit larger than the related cabin on Solidarity of the Seas however smaller than the only on Carnival Breeze. Such rooms have a queen mattress, a settee that converts right into a unmarried mattress and a pull-down bunk.
Harmony of the Seas interior cabin
An inside cabin aboard Solidarity of the Seas (Picture courtesy of Royal Caribbean Global)

Buying and selling As much as a Balcony Cabin: The Differential Remains the Similar

Now and again the most affordable cabin on a boat simply received’t do, so we additionally priced the price of buying and selling as much as a balcony cabin on every of the vessels — an workout that is helping for instance two large issues.

First: A “splurge” on a balcony cabin as opposed to an inside of cabin isn’t just about as expensive as many of us assume. For all 3 of our ships, the improve added not up to 10% to the whole price of the travel.

2d: The top class you’ll pay for a Disney or Royal Caribbean send as opposed to a Carnival send is kind of the similar when reserving a balcony as it’s when reserving an entry-level cabin. On this case, we discovered our relations of 4 would pay about 70% extra to get on Solidarity of the Seas than Carnival Breeze and 169% extra to get on Disney Myth. In particular:

  • The least pricey balcony cabin on Carnival Breeze would have price our relations $3,259.88 (a median of $684 consistent with consumer, plus taxes and charges). For that they’d have got a Cove Balcony that has mainly the similar footprint because the in the past priced inside cabin (its inside house is a similar 185 sq. ft) with the addition of a 45-square-foot balcony.
  • The least pricey balcony cabin to be had on Solidarity of the Seas prices $5,539.80 ($1,283.75 consistent with consumer, plus taxes and charges). For that, you get a cabin overlooking the send’s Boardwalk amusement house with 182 sq. ft of inside house and a 52-square-foot balcony.
Harmony of the Seas junior suite
Solidarity of the Seas junior suite (Picture courtesy of Royal Caribbean Global)
  • The least pricey balcony cabin on Disney Myth prices $8,781.92 ($2,100.14 consistent with consumer, plus taxes and charges). This for what the road calls a Deluxe Oceanview Stateroom with Prolonged Veranda — Mickey positive has a passion for lengthy names. Those cabins have 203 sq. ft of inside house, plus a 43-square-foot balcony.
Disney Dream (Photo by Summer Hull/The Points Guy)
Disney Dream (Picture via Summer time Hull/The Issues Man)

Comparable: The Absolute best Credit score Playing cards for Reserving Cruises

Going Giant With Suites and Concierge-Degree Carrier

For the ones keen to splurge on even larger cabins and upgraded carrier, the comparisons between the ships get extra difficult.

Carnival provides slightly few suites on maximum of its vessels. Fewer than 75 of the 1,845 cabins on Carnival Breeze are suites. The road additionally lacks a top class “concierge category” of cabins that include devoted concierge carrier and different extras.

Royal Caribbean’s contemporary vessels, in contrast, are awash with suites in quite a lot of sizes, together with monumental (and super-pricy), two-deck-high complexes which might be some of the most opulent lodging at sea. Royal Caribbean, in recent times, additionally has added a concierge-class-like program for suite passengers on a few of its vessels (Solidarity of the Seas amongst them). Referred to as Royal Suite Elegance, it provides extra polished carrier and unique get right of entry to to shipboard eating places, lounges and sights.

Like Carnival, Disney provides slightly few suites on its ships. Simply 21 of the 1,250 cabins on Disney Myth are suites. However the line does be offering unique Concierge cabins that include get right of entry to to a concierge staff that may assist organize onboard actions and products and services. On Disney Myth, the Concierge carrier is to be had with all 21 suites, plus 20 nonsuite Concierge Circle of relatives Oceanview Stateroom with Verandah cabins. Along with concierge carrier, all 41 rooms include get right of entry to to a non-public concierge front room and solar deck. Different perks come with precedence boarding.

For our hypothetical relations:

  • The least pricey suite on Carnival Breeze — a 340-square-foot Ocean Suite — priced at $4,784.88 ($1,065.25 consistent with consumer, plus taxes and charges). That is, significantly, nonetheless 40% more cost effective than even the least pricey cabin to be had on Disney Myth.
  • For the suite lifestyles on Royal Caribbean, our relations would pay a minimum of $7,702.80 ($1,824.50 consistent with consumer, plus taxes and charges). That’s for a Junior Suite, which measures 367 sq. ft.
  • The least pricey suite on Disney Myth priced at a stratospheric $21,742.56 ($5,340.30 consistent with consumer, plus taxes and charges). That’s for a 622-square-foot Concierge 1-Bed room Suite with Verandah. That stated, you’ll be able to get into one of the crucial nonsuite Concierge cabins for roughly part that price. Disney doesn’t name the ones cabins suites, however they measure a good 306 sq. ft. That’s no longer a lot smaller than the smallest suites at the different ships.

What’s Integrated and What’s Now not

As common cruisers know, the fares that traces quote for sailings come with extra than simply your accommodation. For the entire ships in our comparability, the cost additionally contains breakfast, lunch and dinner (at primary eating places and buffets); nightly leisure in showrooms; and a vital swath of onboard actions. What’s no longer incorporated are alcoholic and, in some instances, nonalcoholic beverages (Disney provides unfastened sodas on its ships; the others don’t); foods at “forte” eating places; spa and salon products and services; shore excursions and a few onboard actions.

We received’t run thru each and every more fee right here. However imagine that you simply’ll pay round $6 to $7 for a lager on all 3 ships, and a cocktail can run anyplace from $7 to $14 (typically, Solidarity of the Seas has the best possible drink costs). Amongst extra-charge eating places, you’ll discover a flat charge of $38 consistent with consumer on the signature steakhouse on Carnival Breeze, a tad not up to the $43-per-person fee for the Chops Grille steakhouse on Solidarity of the Seas. Disney Myth doesn’t have a steakhouse, however its signature, adults-only Palo eatery is within the ballpark at an extra $40 consistent with consumer.

You’ll additionally pay more for the carrier fees that experience turn out to be common on ships. For many cabins on Carnival, Royal Caribbean and Disney vessels, a relations of 4 would pay $391.72, $406 and $378 a week, respectively, in such charges. Passengers in suites pay extra.

The base line: It’s frustratingly simple for a relations of 4 on any of those ships to run up $1,000 or extra in more fees.

Circle of relatives Sights

Each and every of the ships in our comparability is likely one of the maximum alluring of their respective fleets for households. You’ll in finding watery play zones, relations swimming pools and different kiddie lures at the peak decks of all 3 vessels, and a number of supervised child zones of their interiors.

In particular, Carnival has loaded the highest of Carnival Breeze with one among its signature, family-focused WaterWorks waterpark spaces that has two large waterslides, a soaking “sell off bucket” and different get-you-wet options; a suspended-in-the-sky ropes direction; a miniature golfing direction; and a basketball court docket. Circle of relatives sights at the inside the vessel come with a 3-d theater with shifting seats and particular results (a cruise send rarity).

To not be outdone, Disney has given Disney Myth probably the most leading edge deck-top sights at sea, the 765-foot-long AquaDuck “water coaster.” Disney Myth’s peak deck is also house to a relations pool, kiddie waterslide, kiddie play house, miniature golfing direction and basketball court docket. Its insides are loaded with one of the maximum elaborate youngsters’s play spaces at sea — all Disney themed, in fact.

Disney Fantasy waterslide
Disney Myth’s waterslide (Picture courtesy of Disney Cruise Line)

Nonetheless, in terms of family-friendly sights, neither Carnival Breeze nor Disney Myth comes as regards to providing the array of choices to be had on Solidarity of the Seas.

At 226,963 gross sign in heaps, the send is set 75% larger than its two competition, and all that more room permits for a loopy array of amusements. You’ll discover a waterpark house with 3 huge slides; a separate dry slide that plunges 9 decks (Royal Caribbean says it’s 10, however don’t be fooled; it counts a Deck 13 that doesn’t exist); 3 primary swimming pools and separate browsing swimming pools; a watery kiddie play zone; two rock-climbing partitions; a miniature golfing direction; a basketball court docket; and a zipper line. There’s additionally an outside Boardwalk house that mimics the Jersey Shore with a carousel and arcade. Teenagers have their very own onboard disco, a part of inside child zones unfold over portions of 2 inside decks.

Harmony of the Seas rock-climbing wall
Solidarity of the Seas’s rock-climbing wall (Picture courtesy of Royal Caribbean Global)

Crowds and Carrier

On all 3 of the ships in our comparability, you’re going to really feel the crowds from time to time (simply ask TPG Circle of relatives founder Summer time Hull, aka Mommy Issues, who lately wrote about the pool house pileup she noticed all over a Disney crusing). That is simply par for the direction on large, mass-market vessels that sail with 1000’s of other people.

Nonetheless, in terms of feeling the jam, there are some vital variations between the 3 ships in our comparability.

For starters, you’ll continuously in finding extra other people packed onto Carnival Breeze than Disney Myth, even supposing the 2 ships are kind of the similar dimension (about 130,000 gross sign in heaps). Carnival Breeze can dangle as much as 4,891 passengers if each and every berth is stuffed, about 22% greater than Disney Myth. The differential is much more notable when you have a look at the “double occupancy” numbers for the 2 ships — the choice of other people they’d raise if two other people occupied each and every cabin. Carnival Breeze’s capability in accordance with double occupancy is 3,690 — just about 48% upper than the related quantity for Disney Myth. Packing in additional other people on a in a similar way sized send is among the key tactics Carnival helps to keep it value level low. Differently is via preserving tight controls on staffing. Carnival Breeze sails with a personnel of one,386 — 72 fewer than Disney Myth. The outcome: A crew-to-passenger ratio, in accordance with general occupancy, of about 1 to a few.Five for Carnival Breeze as opposed to 1 to a few.2 for Disney Myth.

Evaluating crew-to-passenger ratios on ships can be offering a coarse information to their carrier ranges, despite the fact that there are caveats to this means. A vital bite of the additional personnel on Disney Myth are concerned within the send’s leisure program, which is way more elaborate. It doesn’t essentially imply Disney is devoting extra personnel to carrier positions in eating places, bars and different spaces. In the meantime, of the 3 vessels within the comparability, it’s Solidarity of the Seas — the send with, via some distance, the best possible passenger capability — which boasts the most productive crew-to-passenger ratio. Whilst the send can sail with as much as 6,687 other people, it operates with 2,200 workforce. That provides it a crew-to-passenger ratio, in accordance with general occupancy, of round 1 to a few.

Locations and Personal Islands

As famous above, our pricing comparability for the ships assumes an Japanese Caribbean itinerary out of Port Canaveral, Florida. Whilst kind of equivalent, the routings that every of the vessels take aren’t equivalent:

  • Carnival Breeze stops at Amber Cove, Dominican Republic; St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands; San Juan, Puerto Rico; and Grand Turk within the Turks & Caicos.
  • Solidarity of the Seas additionally visits San Juan, however substitutes St. Maarten and Royal Caribbean’s personal island within the Bahamas, Best Day Island at CocoCay, for the opposite ports.
  • Like Carnival Breeze, Disney Myth heads to St. Thomas, however combines it with visits to Tortola within the British Virgin Islands and Disney’s personal island within the Bahamas, Castaway Cay.
Disney Castaway Cay
Disney’s personal island Castaway Cay (Picture via David Roark / Disney Cruise Line)

In the case of personal islands, Royal Caribbean’s Best Day is probably the most elaborate via some distance. The road is simply completing a $200 million overhaul of the getaway that has introduced a significant waterpark with 13 waterslides, together with the tallest one in North The usa; the Caribbean’s biggest freshwater pool; the Caribbean’s biggest wave pool and a balloon journey that takes you up 450 ft above the island. There’s additionally an unique — and costly — personal seaside membership coming in December.

Disney’s Castaway Cay is extra of a standard cruise line personal island with seaside spaces (snorkels, tubes and floats are to be had for hire), a small floating waterslide advanced and video games equivalent to volleyball. You can also hire motorcycles for a little bit of exploring across the island. Paddleboards, kayaks and aquabikes also are to be had.

(Photo by Summer Hull/The Points Guy)
(Picture via Summer time Hull/The Issues Man)

Whilst Carnival doesn’t have a non-public island of its personal, two of the stops on Carnival Breeze’s itinerary are personal port trends constructed via its dad or mum corporate that include their very own pool spaces and extra. The 25-acre Amber Cove building has a sprawling pool with a swim-up bar, waterslides, zip traces and personal cabanas in addition to bars, eating places and retail outlets. The 18-acre Grand Turk Cruise Heart advanced has its personal pool house, seaside spaces and cabanas in addition to bars, eating places and retail outlets.

Amber Cove
Amber Cove (Picture courtesy of Carnival Cruise Line)

The Backside Line

I’ve sailed on a lot of these traces time and again through the years, they usually all be offering so much for households. Which one is best for you? The solution relies on quite a few components explicit to you and your relations: your price range, the ages of your children, their personalities and pursuits in explicit actions and the locations that you simply hope to peer.

For the ones on a good price range, Carnival is tricky to overcome — because the pricing comparability above makes transparent. However if in case you have slightly extra wiggle room together with your pocketbook, there are excellent arguments for paying up for every week with Royal Caribbean or Disney. In the case of the standard of carrier, leisure and eating, it’s slightly little bit of “you get what you pay for” with the traces.

As famous above, you’ll discover a upper ratio of crew-to-passengers on Royal Caribbean and Disney ships, and all the ones more workforce individuals do make a distinction within the revel in. The adaptation is especially notable in terms of leisure choices, with each Royal Caribbean and Disney fielding a lot more elaborate displays with larger casts and name-brand tales. Royal Caribbean’s Solidarity of the Seas, as an example, includes a 90-minute adaptation of one among Broadway’s largest crowd-pleasers, “Grease,” in a hovering theater that places many on Broadway to disgrace, plus an outside “aquatheater” that’s house to dazzling aerial performances. Disney’s ships are chock stuffed with Disney-themed leisure that wins kudos for its excessive manufacturing values.

With its larger choice of “older child” amusements, equivalent to browsing swimming pools and rock-climbing partitions, Solidarity of the Seas is a specifically good selection for households with teenagers. Disney ships, like most of the Disney parks, intention more youthful with their sights and are almost certainly absolute best when your children are within the 6- to 12-year-old vary. Simply remember the fact that you’re paying a hefty “Disney top class” to get on board. If you happen to’re a large Disney fan, it is smart. If you happen to’re no longer, it almost certainly doesn’t.

Is your relations enthusiastic about a cruise holiday? Listed below are some extra insights:

Gene Sloan has written about cruising for greater than 25 years and for a few years oversaw USA TODAY’s award-winning cruise web page, USA TODAY Cruises. He’s sailed on just about 150 ships.

Featured graphic via Abbie Winters

%d bloggers like this: